How do internal vs external MTAs treat the same error code?
Internal and external MTAs handle errors differently:
Internal MTA (your own Postfix, Exim, etc.):
Full SMTP transcript logged. Raw error codes preserved. Custom handling rules possible. Complete diagnostic information. Direct troubleshooting access.
External MTA (ESP, relay service):
Errors may be categorized and abstracted. Detail level depends on provider. May apply their own classification. Dashboard-friendly but less raw data. API access to bounce data.
Same error, different presentation:
550 5.1.1 via internal: Full remote server response in logs. 550 5.1.1 via ESP: "Hard bounce - user not found" category.
Implications:
Internal: More control, more complexity. External: Less detail, more convenience. Deep troubleshooting may require internal access.
Internal MTAs give you the raw transcript; external MTAs give you the summary.
Was this answer helpful?
Thanks for your feedback!